Two Powerful Tools, One Critical Decision
Disinfection is the final defense between your facility’s effluent and the environment — and when done right, it protects public health, ecosystems, and your permit compliance. But which method is best?
Chlorination and UV disinfection are the two most widely used approaches, and each has unique strengths (and trade-offs). Choosing the right solution means balancing regulations, site constraints, safety, and sustainability goals.
How Chlorine Disinfection Works
Chlorine (gas, liquid, or solid) is added to wastewater to kill pathogens by breaking down their cell walls. It’s a chemical disinfection process that’s been around for over 100 years.
Advantages of Chlorine:
-
Proven performance across a wide range of pathogens
-
Residual protection — continues disinfecting in the collection or reuse system
-
Lower capital costs for initial system installation
Limitations:
-
Health & safety concerns with storage and handling
-
Disinfection byproducts (DBPs) like THMs and HAAs
-
Dechlorination may be required before discharge to avoid environmental harm
How UV Disinfection Works
UV disinfection uses ultraviolet light to damage microbial DNA, rendering pathogens unable to reproduce. It’s a physical process — no chemicals, no residuals.
Advantages of UV:
-
Chemical-free and safer for staff
-
No DBPs created — environmentally cleaner
-
Instant disinfection — no retention time needed
-
Ideal for green and reuse projects
Limitations:
-
No residual protection after treatment
-
Requires continuous power and clean lamps for effectiveness
-
Higher capital cost and potential for increased maintenance
How to Choose the Right Disinfection Method
| Consideration | Chlorine | UV |
|---|---|---|
| Residual disinfection needed? | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
| Avoid chemical handling? | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Low energy availability? | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
| Eco-conscious project? | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Space and automation needs? | Tie | ✅ UV is compact & automatable |
Other Factors to Consider:
-
Regulations: Some states require chlorine residuals; others discourage chlorine use
-
Turbidity: High solids can block UV rays — may need pre-treatment
-
O&M staff skills: UV requires different maintenance knowledge than dosing chemicals
-
Lifecycle costs: Don’t just compare install costs — consider chemicals, compliance risk, and energy usage
How BCG Water Helps Clients Make the Right Call
Disinfection is not one-size-fits-all. At BCG Water, we evaluate your entire system — from influent quality to final effluent goals — and recommend fit-for-purpose disinfection strategies that check every box:
-
Compliance
-
Safety
-
Long-term cost-effectiveness
-
Environmental impact
-
Community expectations
Whether you’re upgrading an aging chlorination system or evaluating UV for a new facility, we’ll help you choose with confidence.
Call to Action (CTA)
Ready to design or upgrade your disinfection system?
👉 Talk to a BCG Consultant and find the method that fits your goals, your team, and your budget.