Could a volcano out-seed human cloud seeding efforts?
On January 15, 2022, the Hunga Tonga – Hunga Ha‘apai volcano erupted with a force that stunned scientists around the world. In just a few hours, this underwater volcano released an estimated 146 teragrams (that’s 146 million tons) of water vapor into the stratosphere – enough to fill 58,000 Olympic swimming pools. In an ironic twist, nature had performed a scale of atmospheric moisture injection far beyond anything humans have attempted through cloud seeding.
That eruption may have subtly shifted global weather patterns. It also reignited a question we’ve been asking for decades: Should we be trying to mimic nature with weather modification technologies – or letting Earth take the lead?
What Is Cloud Seeding—and How Does It Work?
Cloud seeding is a form of weather modification where substances like silver iodide or salt are introduced into clouds to encourage precipitation. The idea is to provide particles that water vapor can condense around, potentially triggering rain or snow. This is typically done by aircraft or ground-based generators.
Originally pioneered in the 1940s, cloud seeding has been used for everything from boosting water supply to suppressing hailstorms. However, it’s far from a silver bullet. Results vary widely depending on atmospheric conditions, and the overall effectiveness remains modest at best.
The Rise – and Stall – of Cloud Seeding
Cloud seeding had its heyday in the mid-20th century. Scientists like Vincent Schaefer and Bernard Vonnegut made early breakthroughs, and the technology was rapidly adopted for military and agricultural use. But by the 1970s, enthusiasm waned.
One reason? Operation Popeye – a U.S. military effort to create mud on the Ho Chi Minh trail in Vietnam – sparked ethical and political backlash. The U.S. and other countries signed the ENMOD treaty in 1978, prohibiting hostile environmental modification. Meanwhile, doubts about cloud seeding’s efficacy and concerns about ecological impact led to declining public support and funding.
Why Cloud Seeding Is Returning – and Who’s Paying for It
Today, cloud seeding is making a quiet comeback. Western states like California, Idaho, and Colorado have revived programs to combat drought and boost snowpack. Utility companies and water agencies are investing in seeding as a supplemental tool to stretch water supplies. Even private startups, like Rainmaker, are attracting venture capital.
But controversy still follows. In July 2025, after extreme floods in Texas, a cloud-seeding company became the target of conspiracy theories. Scientists quickly clarified that cloud seeding can’t trigger storms of that magnitude – but the incident highlighted the public’s lingering unease about manipulating the weather.
The Natural Experiment: Volcanic Cloud Seeding
The Hunga Tonga eruption didn’t just shock geologists; it gave climate scientists a rare and enormous data point. The water vapor it injected into the stratosphere may persist for years, subtly warming the atmosphere. Unlike typical volcanic eruptions that cool the planet by releasing aerosols, this one added a greenhouse gas component – raising concerns about long-term climate effects.
Some researchers liken this to a natural geoengineering experiment. The eruption altered stratospheric circulation and possibly contributed to unusual weather patterns in the Southern Hemisphere. In effect, the volcano seeded not just clouds, but a global conversation: Can we ever match, predict, or control the chaotic beauty of Earth’s own atmospheric systems?
Are We Playing God with the Weather?
Here lies the ethical core of the issue. Cloud seeding promises benefits: more water in drought-stricken regions, reduced hail damage, and potential buffers against climate extremes. But the risks are real: uncertain outcomes, downstream consequences, and geopolitical tensions over shared skies.
The Hunga Tonga eruption is a humbling reminder. With one violent burst, nature demonstrated a scale and complexity far beyond our control. If a volcano can inject more water into the atmosphere in a day than all human seeding efforts combined, maybe our best move is to act with humility.
As we navigate a hotter, drier future, cloud seeding may remain a tool in our kit—but never the whole solution. The Earth doesn’t just need tinkering. It needs stewardship.
Contact Us
At BCG Water, we believe smart water decisions start with asking the right questions. If you’re navigating drought, climate extremes, or future water planning, let’s explore solutions that go beyond quick fixes. Contact us to start a conversation about your water system.
